Critical Reading 

 

 By Ainsley Brooks

 

Photojournalism Representation in film

PDF: http://learn.winchester.ac.uk/file.php/1179/week_2_09/photojournalism_representation_in_film.pdf

“Photojournalism” has been defined as everything from freelance fashion photography to daily newspaper press photography. They are described as a “working member of the visual communications staff of a news organisation.
This 146 page document looks at the history of photojournalism, they mention that since the 1930’s photojournalists in motion pictures have been portrayed as everything from screwball and comic relief characters to stubborn and ruthless sideways, they talk about how photojournalists were largely supporting characters who displayed absurd, unethical behaviours. The purpose of this document is to show the research study and how films analysis photojournalism from the mid-1950s to present day.
Authors like Matthew Ehrlich said, “movies have portrayed journalists both as upstanding citizens and heroes, as well as outsiders and villains”. However recent Hollywood depictions have transcended this. This document researches how they were analysed and how photojournalists in leading or supporting roles have been portrayed. 

 

Hybrid Documentaries 

Link: http://tobias-lib.uni-tuebingen.de/volltexte/2010/4816/pdf/gedruckte_Dissertation.pdf


This looks at how new hybrid television formats combining documentary and entertaining narrative contents and presentation styles have emergedFor example - docu-dramas, docu-soaps, and documentaries with re-enactment scenes. 

 

  • Honest Truths Documentary Filmmakers on Ethical Challenges in Their Work

Link: http://learn.winchester.ac.uk/file.php/1179/week_7_09/Honest_Truths_--_Documentary_Filmmakers_on_Ethical_Challenges_in_Their_Work.pdf

There is a lot of discussion regarding ethics within Documentaries. This Study provides the challenges that documentary filmmakers, directors and producers have to identify in the practice of their craft. The article looks at how filmmakers felt pressured and they found themselves in situations where they needed to balance ethical responsibly against practical considerations. The article also focuses on the way they represent themselves and how they don’t always tell the ‘truth’. There has been concerns about documentary ethics, controversies have emerged against several documentaries, such as Fahrenheit 9/11, was it accurate in its factual indictment of the Bush administrations geopolitics? One would argue not… 

The article mentions that film makers should ‘honor’ the truth to the viewer, so an ethical obligation to deliver accurate and honestly told stories to avoid controversies and negative press. 

 

Documentary in Different Forms: Patrico Guzman: The Battle for chile 

Link: http://www.nfb.ca/film/capturing_reality_patricio_guzman/


I watched a three minute clip taken from “Capturing Reality: The Art of Documentary”, Patricio Guzman talks about Chris Marker, he mentions that Marker brought his documentary from him to recreate it for a different audience. He talks about how without his help the Documentary wouldn’t have been made; he mentions that Marker was interested in both him and his film and that he wanted to re-edit it for different cultures. From this clip, this shows that documentary filmmakers must sometimes work together in order to make it a worldwide success, which will appeal to all audiences. 

 

Docu definitions trigger modes and terms sheet

Link: http://learn.winchester.ac.uk/file.php/1179/2011-12/docu_defintions_trigger_modes_and_terms_sheet_PDF.pdf



This looks at the documentary definitions, movement, the modes and types of documentary. The term ‘documentary’, credited to John Grierson, is the man person behind the ‘British Documentary Movement’ The article also looks the early staged events, explaining how ‘real’ events were often re-staged for the cameras in studios, especially if events took place in other countries. Audiences at first were accepting these “re-creations” however filmmakers like Robert Flaherty saw the emergence of much more and made films about contemporary life around the globe.
John Grierson was influenced about the thought of the “possibilities” a documentary could capture, he made Documentaries like ‘Industrial Britain (1931) and Housing Problems (1935) which helped him develop filming skills and to experiment with film form, which is still used today. 

The article mentions the approaches developed by Bill Nichols (1991), who suggested the following ‘modes’ of documentary:

The Expository Mode – The voice of god
The Observational Mode – eg. Fly on the wall
The Interactive Mode – the documentary makers acknowledged. Active audience acknowledged
The Reflexive Mode – Awareness of the process
Performative Mode – The filmmaker as participant

The article also explains about the main points of documentary practice looking at the types of genre terms, for example, instructional which is how something works and how to do something and new forms of documentary arising like ‘video diaries’ and ‘docusoaps’.

 

Real reality documentary film

Link: http://learn.winchester.ac.uk/mod/resource/view.php?id=38269 


Documentary film, in the words of Bill Nicholas, is one of the “discourses of sobriety” that claim to tell the ‘truth’, to tell the truth.
Documentaries are made to make history, they want to want to reveal what the audience may not or ready know and by creating a documentary this enables them to get the message across.

But how real is a documentary? And are they sometimes ‘overly’ exploiting the documentary through the use of editing or is the voice of god saying things in a certain way, which may make the viewer side with him? All these are covered in this book, but the end result is to not believe everything you see, but to believe what you believe is the truth.

 

Canon 450d Visual Guide

Link: http://learn.winchester.ac.uk/file.php/1179/2011_-_2012_updates/week_3_camera/450d_visual_guide_PP.pdf

This reading was suggested before we took photos for our photo essay, this guide explains how to use a Canon 450D camera, it looks at how the different functions on offer. The guide also tells you how to use the menu on the screen and what each option means and what it is used for. It tells you how to change the white balance, using the the different modes on the top of the camera and so on. 

 

 Critical Reading: Books

 

Book:
Photo Journalism: the professionals' approach.
By Kobre, Kenneth, London : Focal 2008

Book:
Eyewitness: 150 years of photojournalism.
By
Lacayo, Richard; Russell, George, New York : Time 1995

Reading notes: 

This book focuses on the technical side and how to analysis photographs.

Anne Wells says in this book “When the idea of being a photojournalist was a blissful daydream, I stumbled across Photojournalism: The Professional’s Approach. It was everything I was looking for. It answered every question I had and was a clear decisive tool to help me on my way.

 

Reading notes:

In preparation to my Photo Essay I looked at “Eyewitness: 150 years of photojournalism”. 

This book looks at the past 150 years in photojournalism from the beginning, global news, conscience, magazine days, new directions and resurgence.

 

Book:
Photojournalism: the world's top photographers and the stories behind their greatest images.
By
Steel, Andy, Hove : RotoVision 2006

Book:
A New History Of Documentary Film, Ellis, Jack C, McLane, Betsy, London : Continuum 2005

Reading notes: 

The World’s top photographers book was extremely useful and influenced me for my own photo essay. This book looks at some photographers talking about their career and referring to the photos they have taken. For the photos they have taken refer to my photojournalism page.  

“These pictures and the people who took them serve as a catalyst that stirs our awareness, intelligence, and above all, conscience. The photographs throughout this book are cross section samples of the state of our wonderful and over evolving planet. The world really is your oyster.” – Andy Steel

 

Reading notes: 

This book is an introduction to Documentary, looking at the early beginning, the avant-garde, the institutionalization within the UK and the States, the expansion, direct cinema & cinema verite and the future.

The book teaches “Our history of social documentary is a story of determined individuals who over come every kind of obstacle to put their messages on the screen.” (P337)

 

Book:
Introduction to Documentary, Nichols, Bill, Bloomington, Ind. : Indiana University Press 2010

 

 “Documentary films present the facts about a person or an event; it is a form of entertainment that enacts a story by sound and a sequence of images giving the illusion of continuous movement”

- Definition 



"A majority of this country opposes this war, a majority of this country never voted for this administration" 

- Michael Moore


Reading notes: 

This book looks at the important issues in documentary history and criticism. This book teaches the viewer how to read documentary films. The author talks about how documentaries create issues and topics to the viewer. The book also contains lots of information on the different modes, styles, history and expansion of documentary films.

Here are 3 things they say about documentaries (page 7):

1. “Documentaries are about reality: they’re about something that actually happened.”
2. “Documentaries are about real people.”
3. “Documentaries tell stories about what happens in the real world.”

 

A photograph is a secret about a secret. The more it tells you the less you know.

- Diane Arbus

 

 

This free website was made using Yola.

No HTML skills required. Build your website in minutes.

Go to www.yola.com and sign up today!

Make a free website with Yola